This is not medical advice. General information for self-tracking only. If you have kidney disease, have been told your kidney function is reduced, or have diabetes or another condition that affects what you eat, talk to a doctor or a registered dietitian before you raise your protein intake. The same goes if you are under 18, pregnant or breastfeeding, or have ever had an eating disorder or a difficult relationship with food. The numbers behind MyPlate's own targets are on the health sources page.
What protein leverage says, and why it matters for a calorie count
The protein leverage hypothesis is most closely tied to a group at the University of Sydney, whose trials make up much of this post. Its claim is that people have a strong appetite for protein and a weaker one for everything else, so they keep eating until they have had roughly the protein they are after. Make the food lower in protein and people eat more of it to get there, and the extra calories come along for the ride. Make it higher in protein and they stop sooner.3
The best case for it is a 2014 analysis by the same group of 38 published feeding trials, in which people ate as much as they liked from menus whose protein ran anywhere from 8% to 54% of calories. The higher the share of protein, the fewer calories people ate in total, and that held whether carbohydrate or fat made up the rest.1
If that is right, it changes what the protein number in a macro tracker is for. Most of the advice ties protein to muscle, and the post on whether you need to track macros makes that case. Protein leverage says the same number also sets how hungry you are at a given calorie target, which is a different job. The trials below are how well that second job holds up.
441 fewer calories a day, in a trial with no comparison group
The study most often quoted is from the University of Washington in 2005. Nineteen people went through three diets in order: two weeks at 15% protein on enough food to hold their weight, two weeks at 30% protein on the same calories, then twelve weeks at 30% protein eating as much as they wanted. On that last stretch they ate 441 fewer calories a day than before and lost 4.9 kg, 3.7 kg of it fat. Their leptin fell and their ghrelin rose, the hormone changes that usually push people to eat more, and they still ate less.2
It is a striking result and a weak design. Everyone got the diets in the same order, so there is no group that stayed on 15% protein for the same twelve weeks to compare against. Fat also dropped from 35% to 20% of calories at the same moment protein went up, with carbohydrate held at 50%, so the change was not protein alone.2 The authors suggested this effect of protein may be part of why low-carbohydrate diets cause weight loss when people are not counting.2 The trials that then counted every calorie on low carb and low fat, and found little between them, are in the low carb or low fat post.
Dilute the protein and people snack more, up to a point
The Sydney group tested their idea directly in 2011, on 22 lean people living in for three four-day stays. Each stay offered the same menu of 28 foods, built to taste and look alike, with protein hidden at 10%, 15% or 25% of calories. Dropping from 15% to 10% raised total intake by 12%, mostly from savoury foods eaten between meals. Going up from 15% to 25% did nothing to intake at all.3 On the fourth day, hunger rose more in the hour or two after the 10% protein breakfast than after the 25% one.3
The extra eating on 10% protein did not bring protein intake back up to normal, so the authors themselves called the leverage "incomplete".3 A follow-up paper on the same trial reported 14% more eaten on 10% protein than on 25%, along with a sixfold rise in FGF-21, a hormone the group thinks may carry the signal that protein is low.4 I find that the most interesting part of the paper, but the paper shows only that FGF-21 rose alongside the eating, not that it caused it.
A second trial found the effect only at the top end
A Maastricht University trial in 2013 ran the experiment wider and longer: 79 men and women, twelve days on each of three diets at 5%, 15% and 30% protein, eaten freely. This time low protein did not cause overeating. Intake on 5% protein (about 2,230 calories a day) was close to intake on 15% (about 2,300). It was the high-protein diet that moved: about 1,720 calories a day, some 575 fewer than normal protein, and most of the drop came at meals.5
Hunger ratings across the whole day did not differ, though hunger and the desire to eat swung less over the day on 30% protein. The authors' conclusion was careful. They found support for leverage at the high end, none at the low end, and wrote that it "remains to be shown" whether low protein makes people overeat or is just what happens when they overeat carbohydrate and fat.5 So the two best-controlled trials disagree on which half of the curve is real: Sydney found it below 15%, Maastricht above it.
Swap meat for starch at lunch and dinner, and nothing changed
Of all the trials here, the Penn State one is closest to how people actually eat. In 2008, 18 women of normal weight ate lunch and dinner one day a week, with the main dish secretly set at 10%, 15%, 20%, 25% or 30% protein. The researchers swapped animal protein for starchy ingredients and kept the dishes matched for energy density, fat, taste and appearance. Daily protein rose from 44 g to 82 g across the conditions. Daily calories stayed flat, between 1,807 and 1,887, and hunger and fullness ratings did not differ.6
One day at a time is a weakness here, and so is a sample of 18 women. But this trial removed the thing that could have explained some of the others: the dishes had the same energy density. Swapping protein in for other foods can also change how many calories sit in each bite, and I could not find a way to tell from the bigger trials how much of their effect is protein and how much is that.
Does protein fill you up? Under tight conditions, yes
A 2016 meta-analysis asked the narrower question of whether a higher-protein snack or meal makes people feel fuller over the next few hours. It does. But only five studies met the criteria for the pooled analysis, out of 28 that went into a looser count of which way results pointed, and the authors put a warning in the title. Their conclusion is that higher protein raises fullness "under tightly defined conditions", and that any extrapolation to everyday eating or body weight "must be made cautiously".7
Feeling fuller and eating less are also two different measurements. The Maastricht trial found less eating without a difference in overall hunger scores;5 Penn State found neither.6
What the food surveys show, and what they cannot
The hypothesis gets most of its attention from population data. In a US national survey of 9,042 people, protein fell from 18.2% to 13.3% of calories between the people eating the least and the most ultra-processed food. Total calories went up across those groups while the grams of protein stayed fairly constant, which is the pattern leverage predicts.8 An Australian national survey found the same shape, with average protein at 18.4% of calories and energy intake falling as the protein share rose.9 The NIH inpatient trial on ultra-processed food, where people ate 508 more calories a day on the processed diet, found that the extra came from carbohydrate and fat while protein intake did not move.10 That trial and what it does and does not mean for a food log are covered in the ultra-processed food post.
Surveys like these are weak at showing cause, and the people who use them say so. A 2022 paper by the Sydney group itself, working out when this pattern in survey data is real evidence and when it is an artefact, concluded that "disentangling causality is ultimately beyond the power of observational data alone".12 Kevin Hall at the NIH, writing about US food supply data, found that the share of calories from protein had dropped by only about 1% since the early 1970s. He noted that the model predicts even that small fall could raise intake a lot, and judged that leverage was "unlikely to fully explain" the rise in obesity, though it should not be ignored.11
And in a 2024 cohort of 1,699 Canadians aged 67 to 84, each extra percentage point of calories from protein came with about 77 kJ (18 calories) less eaten a day. But BMI was not associated with total intake at all in that group, so the effect on eating did not carry through to weight.13
Does more protein help when you count the calories anyway?
If you track, the question changes. Protein leverage is about how much people eat when nobody sets a number. When you are counting calories, the target sets the number, and protein can only change how hard the target is to hit, and perhaps what the weight you lose is made of.
A 2012 meta-analysis pulled together 24 trials and 1,063 people on calorie-restricted diets with the same calories and fat, differing only in how much of the rest was protein or carbohydrate. Over an average of about 12 weeks, the higher-protein diets lost 0.79 kg more weight and 0.87 kg more fat, and kept 0.43 kg more fat-free mass. The authors called these "modest benefits". On appetite, greater satiety on high protein was reported in three of the five studies that measured it.14
The best long trial with free eating is the European Diogenes study. It took 773 adults who had already lost at least 8% of their weight on an 800-calorie diet run by the study, then randomised them to one of five diets for 26 weeks to see who kept it off. Those assigned to higher protein regained 0.93 kg less than those assigned to lower protein. Fewer of them dropped out, too: 26.4% against 37.4% in the low-protein, high-glycaemic-index group. The authors described the protein difference as "modest".15 An 800-calorie diet is well below anything a self-tracking app should set, and MyPlate never goes under 1,200 calories for women or 1,500 for men, the top of the low-calorie ranges in the NHLBI guidelines.17
So under calorie control, the effects are real and small: under a kilogram over three months in the meta-analysis, under a kilogram of regain over six months in Diogenes. The 441 calories from the Washington trial do not show up as anything like that size once someone is counting.
What the evidence does not settle
Whether leverage works at both ends. Sydney found people overate when protein went below 15%, and Maastricht did not; Maastricht found people ate less above 15%, and Sydney found no change going from 15% to 25%.35 Both trials disguised the food and both were short. Nobody has explained the disagreement.
Whether it lasts. The trials that measured intake directly ran for four or twelve days, plus the twelve uncontrolled weeks in Washington.235 I could not find a randomised trial that measured free eating on high versus normal protein, with matched energy density, for months.
How much is protein and how much is the food around it. The one trial that matched energy density found nothing.6 That does not prove energy density explains the rest, but nobody has ruled it out.
Whether it applies to you. The Sydney, Maastricht and Penn State trials were in lean or, on average, normal-weight adults, the older Canadian cohort found intake effects with no link to body weight,13 and none of these studies looked at what happens to someone who is already logging every meal.
What a macro tracking app can do with this, and what it cannot
On a weight-loss goal, MyPlate sets protein at 28% of the calorie target, inside the 10% to 35% range the National Academies give for adults.16 That share happens to sit close to the 30% the Washington and Maastricht trials used, but those trials are too short and too small to justify any one number. Take a 45-year-old woman, 165 cm and 80 kg, lightly active. The app gives her 1,689 calories and 118 g of protein.
What an app can show you is the gap between that target and what you actually ate, meal by meal, which is the only part of this you can act on. What it cannot see is your hunger. No app knows whether the 4pm snack happened because lunch was 15 g of protein or because you were bored, and a photo scan of a meal is an estimate, so the protein figure on any single plate can be off. Logging a weight does not change the target either.
How to use protein against hunger in macro tracking for weight loss
Keep the calorie target. Nothing above suggests protein can replace it, and under calorie control the extra weight lost was under a kilogram.14
Look at a normal week first. If your logged protein already sits near the target, there is no lever left to pull, and pushing past 35% of calories takes you outside the range the National Academies set.16 If it sits well under, say 70 g a day for the woman above, which is about 17% of her calories, closing the gap is roughly 48 g more protein, about 190 calories. Those 190 have to come out of carbohydrate or fat for the total to stay put. In the feeding trials above, protein went up as something else came down.
Put the protein before the part of the day you lose control of. This is my reading of the Sydney trial rather than something it tested: the extra eating there came as savoury snacks between meals, and hunger climbed after the low-protein breakfast.3 If your log shows the evening is where the target goes, that is the meal before it to change. The protein per meal post covers what the trials say about spreading it out.
Then give it two weeks and judge it by one question: is the calorie target easier to hit? If it is, keep it. If nothing changes, you may be one of the Penn State women, for whom swapping starch for protein did nothing to appetite.6 The protein still does its job for muscle, and the hunger needs a different fix.
If you have any doubt about your kidneys, read the post on protein and kidneys before raising your intake. And if counting grams of anything is starting to make you anxious about food, stop and talk to someone.
Common questions
Does eating more protein make you eat less?
Sometimes, in short trials. A 2005 study found people ate 441 fewer calories a day after protein went from 15% to 30% of their diet, and a 2013 trial found about 575 fewer on 30% protein than on 15%. But a 2011 trial found no change going from 15% to 25%, and a study that matched meals for energy density found no change from 10% up to 30%.2356
What is the protein leverage hypothesis?
It is the idea that people eat until they reach a target amount of protein, so a diet lower in protein leads to more calories eaten and a diet higher in protein leads to fewer. Survey data fits that pattern, but the researchers who proposed it say observational data alone cannot show cause, and the controlled trials disagree about where the effect appears.112
Is a high-protein diet better for weight loss if the calories are the same?
Slightly. A meta-analysis of 24 trials with matched calories found higher-protein diets lost 0.79 kg more weight and 0.87 kg more fat over about 12 weeks, and kept a little more lean mass. The authors called the benefits modest.14
How much protein do you need to feel full when tracking macros for weight loss?
No study gives a number that works for everyone. The trials that found people ate less used about 30% of calories from protein, while one that went from 10% to 30% found no change. MyPlate sets 28% on a weight-loss goal, inside the 10% to 35% range the National Academies give for adults.25616
What is the best macro tracking app if hunger is the problem?
One you will use at every meal, because the useful information is where in the day your protein runs short, and a log with gaps cannot show that. No study has compared macro tracking apps on hunger. MyPlate shows protein alongside calories for each meal you photograph or describe, but it cannot measure your hunger and its scans are estimates.
Count the calories, then let the protein work on the hunger
The idea behind protein leverage is tidier than the evidence for it. Some short trials show people eating hundreds of calories less on high protein, others show nothing, and the long trials under calorie control show gains of under a kilogram. For someone who already counts, the useful version is small and testable: hit the calorie target, move protein toward the target by swapping rather than adding, put it ahead of the hungry part of the day, and see after two weeks whether the number got easier to hold.
Sources
- Gosby AK, Conigrave AD, Raubenheimer D, Simpson SJ (2014). Protein leverage and energy intake. Obesity Reviews, 15(3):183-191. Read on PubMed →
- Weigle DS, Breen PA, Matthys CC, et al. (2005). A high-protein diet induces sustained reductions in appetite, ad libitum caloric intake, and body weight despite compensatory changes in diurnal plasma leptin and ghrelin concentrations. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 82(1):41-48. Read on PubMed →
- Gosby AK, Conigrave AD, Lau NS, et al. (2011). Testing protein leverage in lean humans: a randomised controlled experimental study. PLoS One, 6(10):e25929. Read on PubMed →
- Gosby AK, Lau NS, Tam CS, et al. (2016). Raised FGF-21 and triglycerides accompany increased energy intake driven by protein leverage in lean, healthy individuals: a randomised trial. PLoS One, 11(8):e0161003. Read on PubMed →
- Martens EA, Lemmens SG, Westerterp-Plantenga MS (2013). Protein leverage affects energy intake of high-protein diets in humans. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 97(1):86-93. Read on PubMed →
- Blatt AD, Roe LS, Rolls BJ (2011). Increasing the protein content of meals and its effect on daily energy intake. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 111(2):290-294. Read on PubMed →
- Dhillon J, Craig BA, Leidy HJ, et al. (2016). The effects of increased protein intake on fullness: a meta-analysis and its limitations. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 116(6):968-983. Read on PubMed →
- Martínez Steele E, Raubenheimer D, Simpson SJ, Baraldi LG, Monteiro CA (2018). Ultra-processed foods, protein leverage and energy intake in the USA. Public Health Nutrition, 21(1):114-124. Read on PubMed →
- Grech A, Sui Z, Rangan A, Simpson SJ, Coogan SCP, Raubenheimer D (2022). Macronutrient (im)balance drives energy intake in an obesogenic food environment: an ecological analysis. Obesity, 30(11):2156-2166. Read on PubMed →
- Hall KD, Ayuketah A, Brychta R, et al. (2019). Ultra-processed diets cause excess calorie intake and weight gain: an inpatient randomized controlled trial of ad libitum food intake. Cell Metabolism, 30(1):67-77. Read on PubMed →
- Hall KD (2019). The potential role of protein leverage in the US obesity epidemic. Obesity, 27(8):1222-1224. Read on PubMed →
- Senior AM, Raubenheimer D, Simpson SJ (2022). Testing the protein-leverage hypothesis using population surveillance data. Royal Society Open Science, 9(9):220756. Read on PubMed →
- Honfo SH, Senior AM, Legault V, et al. (2024). Evidence for protein leverage on total energy intake, but not body mass index, in a large cohort of older adults. International Journal of Obesity, 48(5):654-661. Read on PubMed →
- Wycherley TP, Moran LJ, Clifton PM, Noakes M, Brinkworth GD (2012). Effects of energy-restricted high-protein, low-fat compared with standard-protein, low-fat diets: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 96(6):1281-1298. Read on PubMed →
- Larsen TM, Dalskov SM, van Baak M, et al. (2010). Diets with high or low protein content and glycemic index for weight-loss maintenance. New England Journal of Medicine, 363(22):2102-2113. Read on PubMed →
- Institute of Medicine (2005). Dietary Reference Intakes for Energy, Carbohydrate, Fiber, Fat, Fatty Acids, Cholesterol, Protein, and Amino Acids. The National Academies Press, Washington DC. Read the report →
- National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, NIH (1998). Clinical Guidelines on the Identification, Evaluation, and Treatment of Overweight and Obesity in Adults. NIH Publication 98-4083. Read the guidelines →
The formulas and limits behind MyPlate's own numbers, with their citations, are on the health sources page.
