This is not medical advice. General information for self-tracking only. If you have diabetes or raised blood sugar, take insulin or a medicine that lowers blood sugar, or have heart, liver or kidney disease, talk to a doctor or a registered dietitian before you change how much sugar or carbohydrate you eat. The same goes if you are under 18, pregnant or breastfeeding, or have ever had an eating disorder or a difficult relationship with food. The numbers behind MyPlate's own targets are on the health sources page.
Why sugar gets the blame
Sugar has a reputation that no other carbohydrate has. Plenty of diet advice treats it as the thing that makes people fat, apart from the calories it carries, and people who already log every meal often feel they should cut it as well. If that is right, a calorie log is missing something. If not, it isn't.
First, what is being talked about. The World Health Organization uses the term free sugars: sugars "added to foods and drinks by the manufacturer, cook or consumer", plus the sugars naturally in honey, syrups and fruit juice. Its guideline does not cover the sugar in fresh fruit and vegetables or the sugar naturally in milk, "because there is no reported evidence of adverse effects of consuming these sugars".1
Much of it is not where people look. WHO's own examples are a tablespoon of ketchup, with around 4 grams of free sugars, and a can of sugar-sweetened soda, with up to 40 grams.1 Sugar is a carbohydrate, counted at the same 4 calories per gram as starch,2 so a calorie count already includes it. The open question is whether it needs a count of its own.
Swap sugar for other carbs, keep the calories, and the weight stays put
The cleanest test is to keep the calories the same and change only where the carbohydrate comes from. A 2013 review for the BMJ, from the University of Otago, pooled 30 randomised trials and 38 cohort studies. In the trials where sugars were swapped for other carbohydrates at the same calories, body weight did not change: a difference of 0.04 kg, with a 95% confidence interval from 0.04 kg less to 0.13 kg more.3 The authors' own conclusion was that the weight change seen with more or less sugar "seems to be mediated via changes in energy intakes".3
A 2012 meta-analysis in Annals of Internal Medicine asked the same of fructose, the half of table sugar that gets most of the blame. Across 31 trials in 637 people where fructose replaced other carbohydrate at similar calories, it had no overall effect on weight: 0.14 kg less, with an interval from 0.37 kg less to 0.10 kg more.4 The authors were frank about their material. The trials "tended to be small (<15 participants), short (<12 weeks), and of low quality".4
One thing to keep in mind with the BMJ review: it left out weight-loss trials on purpose.3 So it says what sugar does to weight at the same calories, not what happens on a diet. For that there are a couple of older trials.
43% of calories from sugar on a diet, and the same weight loss
In 1997 a Duke University group put 42 women with obesity on a six-week weight-loss diet of about 4,606 kJ a day, roughly 1,100 calories, with the food low in fat. The diets were the same except for one thing. For 20 of the women, 43% of the calories came from sucrose, table sugar. For the other 22 it was 4%.5
Both groups lost weight and body fat, and hunger and low mood fell in both. The authors concluded that a high sucrose content in that diet "did not adversely affect weight loss, metabolism, plasma lipids, or emotional affect".5 Two cautions. Six weeks is short. And about 1,100 calories a day is a supervised research diet, below the lowest target MyPlate will ever set, so the trial says something about sugar and nothing about how low to go.
The European CARMEN trial ran longer and let people eat freely. It randomised 398 adults with moderate obesity for six months to a control diet, a low-fat diet high in simple carbohydrates such as sugar, a low-fat diet high in complex carbohydrates such as starch, or no change at all. The two low-fat groups lost 0.9 kg and 1.8 kg, and the authors reported no significant difference in weight change between the simple and complex carbohydrate versions.6 The larger loss on complex carbs is there in the numbers. The trial was not able to say it was real.
Where sugar does move the scale: when nobody is counting
The same BMJ review that found nothing at matched calories found an effect when people ate freely. In trials of adults on their usual diets, cutting sugars went with 0.80 kg less body weight, and adding sugars with 0.75 kg more.3 Since swapping sugar for other carbs at the same calories did nothing, the plain reading is that sugar changes how many calories people eat when nothing else holds the number down.
A 2002 Danish trial shows what that can look like. For ten weeks, 41 adults with overweight got daily foods and drinks sweetened with either sucrose or artificial sweeteners, and otherwise ate as they liked. The sucrose supplements gave about 152 grams of sugar a day, mostly in drinks. The sucrose group ended up eating about 1.6 MJ, around 380 calories, more a day than before and gained 1.6 kg. The sweetener group lost 1.0 kg.7
The fructose meta-analysis found the same pattern from the other side. When fructose was added on top of a normal diet, at 104 to 250 grams a day, weight went up by 0.53 kg on average, and the authors said that "may be due to the extra calories rather than the fructose".4 In the Danish trial most of the sugar came as drinks, which slip past appetite more easily than food does. The liquid calories post covers that part.
Same weight, different fat: the fructose trial
Weight is not the only thing anyone cares about, and this is where the case against sugar has its strongest single study. In a 2009 trial at UC Davis, adults with overweight or obesity drank glucose- or fructose-sweetened drinks providing 25% of their energy needs for ten weeks. Both groups gained a similar amount of weight. Only the fructose group gained visceral fat, the fat around the organs, and only the fructose group saw their insulin sensitivity fall.8
Be exact about what this tested, though. The drinks were sweetened with pure fructose or pure glucose, not table sugar, which is half of each. A quarter of the day's energy as sweet drinks is a lot. And the comparison was fructose against glucose, not sugar against no sugar. It is a reason to think sugar is not neutral for health at high doses. It does not say a teaspoon in your coffee changes where your fat goes on a calorie target, and no trial I found tested that.
People log less sugar than they eat
This part matters most if you track food. A 2015 study in the EPIC-Norfolk cohort followed 1,734 adults for three years and measured their sugar intake two ways: from seven-day food diaries, and from the amount of sucrose in a urine sample, which tracks what people actually ate. The two methods pointed in opposite directions. By the urine measure, more sucrose went with a higher risk of being overweight three years later. By the diaries, more reported sucrose went with a lower one.9
The study does not say why. One possibility is that people who weighed more wrote down less of the sugar they ate, which would flip the result. This study cannot show that, but it shows clearly that a food diary and a biomarker can disagree about sugar, and the authors recommended that future studies use the biomarker.9
If you are counting calories to lose weight, this is where sugar actually costs you. Sugar you forget to log is calories you forget to log: the spoonful in tea, or the sauce on a stir-fry. None of it looks like much on the plate, and it all counts.
Low fat on the label, more sugar inside
One more place sugar hides. A 2016 Stanford comparison went through the USDA nutrient database and set fat-free, low-fat and regular versions of the same foods side by side. The low-fat and fat-free versions had more sugar than the regular ones, with the difference statistically significant.10 The study compared sugar, not calories, so it does not make the low-fat version worse. It does mean the word on the front of the pack tells you about the fat and nothing about the sugar. The calories on the back are the number to log.
Why the WHO still says under 10%
If sugar does nothing special to weight at matched calories, why the limit? WHO's guideline recommends that adults and children keep free sugars below 10% of total energy, a recommendation it rates strong, and suggests that below 5%, roughly 25 grams a day, would bring further benefits, a recommendation it rates conditional.1
The reasons are mostly not about calorie counting. WHO's evidence was that people who eat less sugar weigh less, that eating more is associated with gaining weight, and that tooth decay is more common above 10%. The 5% figure rests largely on dental studies from a period when sugar was scarce, which is why WHO calls it conditional.1 A 2023 umbrella review in the BMJ pulled together 73 meta-analyses and found harmful associations between sugar and dozens of outcomes, but most of them came from observational studies. Its moderate-quality findings were higher body weight with sugar-sweetened drinks and more fat in the liver and other organs with added sugars.11
For weight, then, the trials say sugar works through calories. For health, there are reasons to keep it modest that a calorie count does not capture, and I don't think a calorie target excuses ignoring them.
What the evidence does not settle
Whether sugar changes body composition on a calorie target. The fructose trial found visceral fat changes at the same weight gain, but with pure fructose, at a quarter of energy, in ten weeks.8 I could not find a trial that tested ordinary amounts of table sugar during a calorie deficit and measured where the fat went.
How good the matched-calorie trials are. The fructose meta-analysis called most of its trials small, short and of poor quality.4 The no-difference result is consistent across reviews, but it is built on weak bricks.
Whether sugar is addictive. It is a popular claim. A 2016 review from Cambridge found "little evidence to support sugar addiction in humans", and said the binge-like behaviour seen in rats appears only with intermittent access to sugar and likely comes from palatable food rather than from sugar's effects in the brain.12 If sweet food is hard for you to stop eating, that is real and worth taking seriously. The review just does not support calling it an addiction to the molecule.
Whether the cohort studies are measuring sugar at all. The EPIC-Norfolk result suggests self-reported sugar can point the wrong way.9 Much of the observational evidence on sugar, on both sides of the argument, rests on self-report.
What a calorie and nutrient tracker can see about sugar, and what it cannot
MyPlate does not count sugar. A scan gives calories, protein, carbohydrate and fat, and sugar sits inside the carbohydrate figure without a line of its own. There is no sugar target, and no barcode scanner to read it off a packet. If you need a sugar number, for diabetes or because a clinician asked you to, use a tool that tracks it.
Where the app does help is the sugar you cannot see, which is where the EPIC-Norfolk diaries went wrong. A photo of a cup of tea does not show the spoonful in it, and a stir-fry does not show the sauce. When MyPlate adds an ingredient like that because it is usually there, the row is marked "Added, often hidden", and under "What I went with" the scan lists it as a guess. Tap the guess and you can answer "Was this used?", swap it for another amount or remove it, with the calorie change shown before you pick. If a lot was left to guess, the dish says "Rough estimate", so you know the number is loose.
Typing works too. Write "black coffee, no sugar" or "tea with two sugars" and the app does not have to guess what went in. A scan is still an estimate, not a measurement, and the app cannot see a sauce that was cooked into the food.
How to handle sugar when counting calories to lose weight
Count the calories first. They decide the weight, and sugar is already in them. MyPlate sets your target from your sex, age, height, weight, activity and goal, and never below 1,200 calories a day for women or 1,500 for men, the top of the low-calorie ranges in the NHLBI guidelines.13 Cutting sugar is not a reason to go below that.
Then, if you want a sugar limit, work it out from the target. WHO's 10% of energy is easy to convert because sugar is counted at 4 calories a gram.12 On an 1,800-calorie target, 10% is 180 calories, which is 45 grams of free sugars. The 5% figure is about 22 grams on that target. For comparison, MyPlate's weight-loss split puts 45% of calories in carbohydrate, about 200 grams at 1,800, so the WHO limit is under a quarter of your carbs.
Look at drinks before food. In the Danish trial where added sugar put weight on, most of it arrived as drinks,7 and a single can of soda can carry most of a day's 10%.1 Swapping that is the change most likely to matter.
Log the hidden sugar rather than banning it. Honey on porridge and sauce on dinner are small, frequent and easy to forget. Logging them is what the diaries in EPIC-Norfolk appear not to have done.9
Keep the fruit. WHO's limit leaves out the sugar in fresh fruit.1 In three large US cohorts, eating more fruit went with less weight gain over four-year periods, by about half a pound per extra daily serving, though the authors say residual confounding cannot be ruled out.14 Juice is the exception, because WHO counts its sugar as free.1
Whether lower carbohydrate overall helps is a different question, covered in low carb or low fat. And if any of this is making food feel like a set of rules you are failing, stop and talk to a doctor or a registered dietitian. Can calorie tracking cause an eating disorder covers the signs that tracking has stopped helping.
Common questions
Does sugar make you gain weight if you stay within your calories?
Not in the trials that tested it. When sugars replaced other carbohydrates at the same calories, a 2013 BMJ review found no change in body weight, and a 2012 review found the same for fructose. Those trials were mostly small and short, and the fructose review rated most of them low quality.34
Do you need to cut sugar when counting calories to lose weight?
No, not for the weight. In a six-week diet trial, women getting 43% of their calories from sugar lost weight just like women getting 4%. Cutting sugar does help people eat less when they are not counting, and WHO recommends keeping free sugars under 10% of energy for health reasons beyond weight.531
Is the sugar in fruit bad for weight loss?
There is no good evidence that it is. WHO's sugar limit does not cover fresh fruit, and in three large US cohort studies, eating more fruit went with less weight gain over time. Those studies were observational, so they cannot prove fruit caused it. Fruit juice is different: WHO counts its sugar as free sugar.114
How much sugar a day is OK on a calorie target?
WHO recommends free sugars below 10% of total energy, and suggests below 5% for extra benefit. Sugar has 4 calories a gram, so on an 1,800-calorie target 10% is 45 grams and 5% is about 22 grams. The limit does not include sugar in fresh fruit, vegetables or plain milk.1
Does a calorie and nutrient tracker need to count sugar?
For weight loss, not usually. Calories already include sugar's 4 calories a gram, and in the trials sugar changed weight through those calories. A sugar figure matters if you have diabetes or are aiming for WHO's limit. MyPlate does not count sugar separately. It shows carbohydrate, and marks hidden sugar it had to guess, such as in tea or a sauce, so you can change it.31
Count the calories, then watch the drinks
At the same calories, sugar did not change weight in the trials, even at 43% of a diet. Where it does change weight is in how much people eat when nobody is counting, mostly through drinks, and in the sugar that never makes it into the food diary. So if you are counting calories to lose weight, the number already does most of the work. Log the hidden spoonfuls, look at what you drink, keep the fruit, and treat WHO's 10% as a health limit rather than a weight-loss trick.
Sources
- World Health Organization (2015). WHO calls on countries to reduce sugars intake among adults and children. News release, 4 March 2015, on Guideline: sugars intake for adults and children. Read the release →
- Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (2003). Food energy - methods of analysis and conversion factors. FAO Food and Nutrition Paper 77, chapter 3. Read the chapter →
- Te Morenga L, Mallard S, Mann J (2013). Dietary sugars and body weight: systematic review and meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials and cohort studies. BMJ, 346:e7492. Read on PubMed →
- Sievenpiper JL, de Souza RJ, Mirrahimi A, et al. (2012). Effect of fructose on body weight in controlled feeding trials: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Annals of Internal Medicine, 156(4):291-304. Read on PubMed →
- Surwit RS, Feinglos MN, McCaskill CC, et al. (1997). Metabolic and behavioral effects of a high-sucrose diet during weight loss. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 65(4):908-915. Read on PubMed →
- Saris WH, Astrup A, Prentice AM, et al. (2000). Randomized controlled trial of changes in dietary carbohydrate/fat ratio and simple vs complex carbohydrates on body weight and blood lipids: the CARMEN study. International Journal of Obesity, 24(10):1310-1318. Read on PubMed →
- Raben A, Vasilaras TH, Møller AC, Astrup A (2002). Sucrose compared with artificial sweeteners: different effects on ad libitum food intake and body weight after 10 wk of supplementation in overweight subjects. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 76(4):721-729. Read on PubMed →
- Stanhope KL, Schwarz JM, Keim NL, et al. (2009). Consuming fructose-sweetened, not glucose-sweetened, beverages increases visceral adiposity and lipids and decreases insulin sensitivity in overweight/obese humans. Journal of Clinical Investigation, 119(5):1322-1334. Read on PubMed →
- Kuhnle GG, Tasevska N, Lentjes MA, et al. (2015). Association between sucrose intake and risk of overweight and obesity in a prospective sub-cohort of the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer in Norfolk (EPIC-Norfolk). Public Health Nutrition, 18(15):2815-2824. Read on PubMed →
- Nguyen PK, Lin S, Heidenreich P (2016). A systematic comparison of sugar content in low-fat vs regular versions of food. Nutrition & Diabetes, 6(1):e193. Read on PubMed →
- Huang Y, Chen Z, Chen B, et al. (2023). Dietary sugar consumption and health: umbrella review. BMJ, 381:e071609. Read on PubMed →
- Westwater ML, Fletcher PC, Ziauddeen H (2016). Sugar addiction: the state of the science. European Journal of Nutrition, 55(Suppl 2):55-69. Read on PubMed →
- National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, NIH (1998). Clinical Guidelines on the Identification, Evaluation, and Treatment of Overweight and Obesity in Adults. NIH Publication 98-4083. Read the guidelines →
- Bertoia ML, Mukamal KJ, Cahill LE, et al. (2015). Changes in intake of fruits and vegetables and weight change in United States men and women followed for up to 24 years: analysis from three prospective cohort studies. PLoS Medicine, 12(9):e1001878. Read on PubMed →
The formulas and limits behind MyPlate's own numbers, with their citations, are on the health sources page.
